Wednesday, March 24, 2010

General Claims

Chapter eight in the Epstein book is about General Claims. One of the most important things that the first section covered was when and how to use words like all, some, no, and only. Those words are very strong and leave no room for anything else. All means every single one without any exceptions. Some means at least one, so it might be smarter to say some rather than all. An example of this is when someone says " all professors give easy exams". That is saying that every single professor in the world gives easy exams. That is clearly not the case so you would not be making a valid argument if you said all. Now i'll look at it the other way. If someone says "some professors give easy exams", you would be much more inclined to listen to them. It makes sense that some professors give easy exams and that is definitely believable. If you say that all professors give easy exams then you clearly are lying. You have not had all professors, so you do not know. That is a very valid point and this section was very good in explaining that it is important to reason using general claims.

1 comment:

  1. I really like the topic you choose to blog about. I found that it was very interesting and that you broke down the concept that the book was discussing very well. Your example that you used was perfect in order to further understand the concept in the book. You gave very good details about what the book was discussing and you made it easier to understand with the way that you broke down the concept. Overall I think that you did a very good job and it really shows that you understood what it was that you were reading. Good job!

    ReplyDelete